I do not think a "Members' Only" section would be beneficial to the board. Especially if the resulted in two boards. I do think having to register prior to using the board, as with many boards, is not only a good idea but should be mandatory.
Even the post above is posted by an anonymous poster who, if even like Vicki, posted while not logged in would not allow anyone to know, even me, who made the post.
Anyone posting including non-Amazing Charts owners or users should be responsible for their posts.
As such, I have made it so that the next time anyone posts, they will be required to read the user board's rules and agree.
If any user including non-AC users deem that anyone is violating these rules, I would appreciate it if you could point it out to me or another moderator or admin, although I seem to be the only active moderator at this time.
Finally, I do think Jon or I need to find a way so that anonymous users cannot post.