With the CCHIT certification being so onerous on companies like our beloved Amazing Charts, I have written to CCHIT, medical economics, ACP, FTC about the absurdity of fee structure for certification. I would suggest that users of AC think about this (as you are trained to be thinkers), if you feel it is appropriate, so that we the users of AC do not get obsolete, write letters to CCHIT and other forums of medicine/if you belong to other medical organization (eg., ACP, ACS, AGA, AMA etc) the way you feel about this issue.
The links are: for CCHIT first register and then submit public comment-
http://www.cchit.org/comments/register.asphttp://www.cchit.org/comments/comment.aspFor American College of Physicians:
http://www.acponline.org/cgi-bin/feedbackFor Medical Economics:
http://www.memag.com/memag/static/staticHtml.jsp?id=109644https://rn.ftc.gov/pls/dod/wsolcq$.startup?Z_ORG_CODE=PU01
I have enclosed a copy I wrote to CCHIT:
____________________________________________________________
This letter is regarding the fee for CCHIT certification and why you urgently need to change your fee structure and make it easier for small vendors of EMR.
I should say that I don't agree about this certification process just because of what I view as unfair fee. We have been using Amazing Charts EMR for more than 2 yrs, we are happy with the use, the developer Dr. Jon Bertman is a practicing Family Practitioner and is constantly making improvements. We are running a chart-less office (paperless office in common parlance) with Amazing Charts. The program is stable, solid and ideal for small practices.
As I understand it costs an EMR company about $28,000 for 3 yrs and another 9,600 for 2 yrs to maintain the certification process. It costs about $200,000.00 for an EMR company to go through the certification process. These costs will ultimately be borne by public; initially vendors pay, then they pass on to medical practices. Ultimately patients and insurers will pay more, as it will work its way up into payment formulas. This I believe is rather unnecessary and expensive proposition.
Many of the EMRs small practices use EMRs that cost around $1000 (what we use - Amazing charts cost $995.00 for 1 user). The software developer will have to sell 200 copies of software just to pay for this certification process!. This cost will be somewhat fixed for all companies selling EMR. I sincerely hope you will not succeed in your endeavor if your fee is priced as it is now. Your organization may crush small EMR vendors who are doing a terrific job in supporting the small practices throughout the nation. If your main aim is to allow interoperability, then that is already done by many EMR companies in the form of CCR. We have that capability too in Amazing charts. Or on the other hand CCHIT may become obsolete if you keep your current fee structure as only big companies will get certified, pass it on to Physicians, who will totally ignore you as they are not ready to pay those high fee indirectly.
I think the CCHIT certification is absurdly priced, it is not logical in that even the expensively priced ones will have problems on a day to day use as you will find out talking with doctors who use them. I wanted to share my opinion with you regarding what my feelings are and what I think the physicians in USA should do. My opinion and suggestion to doctors in small practices who are contemplating to buy CCHIT products is -- look at the overall cost of ownership say for 20 yrs, or longer if you are going to be around practicing medicine, don't buy products just because they are CCHIT certified. In my opinion it means nothing in running your day to day practice. If you pay $20,000 for just software, close your office for 5 days training to you and your supportive staff, and pay 20-25% support fee per year you will not recoup that money anytime, however you calculate. Many doctors who bought expensive softwares (read CCHIT certified) feel they are stuck with it, as they have already invested heavily in that software and breakups cause a lot of interference in day to day operations.
I also hope CCHIT will not abuse the power it has to twist the arms of Medicare etc to allow only CCHIT certified products to participate in P4P etc.
Hopefully this letter will you some food for thought about your fee. As you have seen already only big companies who charge huge amounts for their software are getting certified by you. I would suggest you visit EMRupdate.com (if you have not done that already) to get a feeling how the physicians and EMR vendors feel about your organization and what you are doing will eliminate the innovation and crush small vendors (This I believe is against the principles on which this great Nation is built upon). And hopefully you will revise your fee structure based on cost of software.
signed----
_____________________________________________________________
Regards.